Kronos Five Decades

March 14, 2023 | Posted by Peter Jakobsen | MUSIC, THUMBNAIL REVIEWS | 1 Comment |

(Adelaide Festival Theatre, 13 March 2023)

Kronos Quartet is not a string quartet: it is an anti-string quartet. “The Kronos Quartet has broken the boundaries of what string quartets do” quoth the holy New York Times. “…the most far-ranging ensemble geographically, nationally, and stylistically the world has known” was the verdict of the somewhat less paper-of-record Los Angeles Times. The group is from Seattle, by way of San Francisco, which is surely a ‘tell.’

Violinists David Harrington and John Sherba, violist Hank Dutt, and cellist Paul Wiancko can play their instruments beautifully, as they demonstrated in the 2nd part of the programme with a sublime modern piece called Enthusiasm Strategies. This was truly a string quartet in action, and the consummate manner of execution made mock of what otherwise was an at times interesting shambles.

For, unfortunately, that piece was buried beneath a play-list of discordant squeaks, shouts, gongs, maracas, muttering, and fiddling with water-tuned crystal glasses, and involved not-so-much playing the violins as beating them black and blue. At times it came across as if three superannuated members of Kraftwerk, and a sumo wrestler, were playing Portishead tunes on household implements.

The opener was George Crumb’s Black Angels, which first inspired Kronos to form in 1973, just as the war in Vietnam was winding down. It’s discord is meant to symbolise the war, but we’ve no idea how. It was akin to a soundtrack to an indie horror film. The 2nd work, ilektrikés rímes, had a structure at least, was written by someone called Aleksandra Vrebalov, featured a recorded Cossack chorus and could instead be titled ‘Taking Kyiv by Strategy.’

The second half started with the ‘world premiere’ of Beak, a paean to the pied butcherbird – by Australian composers Jon Rose and Hollis Taylor. Here, the by-now-all-too-familiar plinking and plunking accompanied an annoying bird, who did most of the work. 

Then alas, back to more discordant bollocks and then 3 Persian songs by Iranian vocalist Mahsa Vahdat, which was indecipherable to non-Arabic speakers: she could have been singing ‘Kill all infidels’ or ‘Impeach Trump’ for all we knew.

The crowd seemed to love it however, which, in the final analysis, is what counts.

1 Comment

  1. Reply

    David M

    March 15, 2023

    We weren’t expecting the repertoire they played! They seem to have evolved into a showmanship style of presentation, but I guess everyone has to do that these days.
    The first piece was, I s’pose, ‘modern’ music but not very musical to people of a certain age… Rapid violin playing and the shift to bowing the water filled glasses created an interesting set of sounds but a little went a long way, I thought. My concern was the lack of transparency of the sound system – the players tapping /slapping the bodies of their instruments and the random shouts overloaded the sound reinforcement system and didn’t sound at all realistic – root cause was the grotty time response of the sound system, which in any event was too loud.
    And the second piece, composed as a reply to the first – well, more of the same, really.
    The bird song and accompaniment was good, but again too loud. The backs to the audience and playing against a moving score was an interesting performance, too.
    And music and politics shouldn’t be mixed. I am sure the Iranian lady is a good singer, but protest songs in a foreign language don’t come over very well to me – perhaps sur-titles should have been provided?

Leave a comment...

While your email address is required to post a comment, it will NOT be published.

Leave a Reply

© Copyright 2014 The Varnished Culture All Rights Reserved. TVC Disclaimer. Site by KWD&D.