Wagner and Modernism

Wagner by Albrecht Leistner, 1911 (photo by Koernerj2000)

Modernism has many adherents and many parents.  It began, more or less, in the late 19th century (particularly in France) and flourished in the 20th century (early on, particularly in Italy – Ezra Pound’s admonition to ‘make it new’ probably reflected his italianate longings).

Although some point to Kant as the great begetter of modernism, there are folks who were closer to home that can stake a better claim.  In France: Édouard Manet, Gustave Flaubert and especially Charles Baudelaire, and rather more globally, Richard Wagner.  Nietzsche regarded Baudelaire in this context as Wagner’s ‘intelligent adherent.’  But surely Wagner takes the prize, both in reach, scope, and time.

In a masterpiece of concision, Roger Scruton wrote:

Three great artists prepared the way for modernism – Baudelaire, Manet and Wagner…Acutely conscious of the death of God, Wagner proposed man as his own redeemer and art as the transfiguring rite of passage to a higher world.  The suggestion was visionary, and its impact on modern culture so great that the shock waves are still overtaking us.  Modern high culture is as much a set of footnotes to Wagner as Western philosophy is, in Whitehead’s judgement, footnotes to Plato.”*

Wagner saw that the death of god meant we could, either: in Chesterton’s phrase, start believing in anything; or make an idol of man; or better yet, transcend the dead flak and flotsam of defeated ‘isms’ and create a new aesthetic.  His aesthetic manifested in new forms arising from revivified myths.  The confrontation between Wagner’s modernism and this post-modern age of ours, results in what we maintain is a decline occurring in high culture.

That decline, of which we have often spoken, shows current trends in a particularly poor light.  Its most pungent emanation obtains in the revisionism of staging of Wagner Operas, particularly in Germany, where nazi symbols serve as a cat’s paw for anarcho-syndicalism.

Scruton again: “modern productions attempt to ‘domesticate’ Wagner, to bring his dramas down from the exalted sphere in which the music places them, to the world of human trivia, usually in order to make a ‘political statement’ which, being both blatant and banal, succeeds only in cancelling the rich ambiguities of the drama.  In contemporary Wagner productions we see exactly what the transition from modernism to the ‘post-modern’ world involves – namely, the final rejection of high culture as a redemptive force, and the ruination of the scared in its last imagined form.”


By E. A. Römhild













[*Scruton, An Intelligent Person’s Guide to Modern Culture, 1998, p.63 (& 64).]


Leave a comment...

While your email address is required to post a comment, it will NOT be published.

Leave a Reply

© Copyright 2014 The Varnished Culture All Rights Reserved. TVC Disclaimer. Site by KWD&D.